Connect with us

E-Financial

Lotus Bank Drags 45 Banks to Court over Alleged ₦1.1Bn Fraudulent Withdrawals

Published

on

Kindly share this post

A Federal High Court sitting in Ikoyi, Lagos, has been asked to intervene in a suit filed by Lotus Bank Limited seeking to recover ₦1,133,808,604.31 allegedly withdrawn by hundreds of its customers following a system failure that hit the bank’s electronic payment platform in July.

Lotus Bank Drags 45 Banks to Court over Alleged ₦1.1Bn Fraudulent Withdrawals

The bank, in its motion on notice filed before Justice Daniel Osiagor, alleged that 718 customers fraudulently withdrew and transferred funds exceeding their account balances after it experienced system failure codename ‘a system glitch’, which occurred on July 20, 2024.

The glitch, the bank explained, resulted from a rollback fix on its E-Bills Pay platform, which temporarily disabled automatic debit processes.

The bank also admitted that during the ‘system failure’, 718 customers who made successful withdrawals and transfers from their accounts knew that they did not have the amounts in their accounts with the bank.

To salvage the unlawful withdrawal caused due to the ‘system glitch’, the 45 banks were dragged before the court by Lotus Bank over the massive financial woe.

Advertisement

The suit according to Lotus Bank is pursuant to Order 3 Rules 1 6, and 9 of the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2019 and under the court’s inherent jurisdiction.

It ask the court for the following questions for determination: “whether having regard to the Central Bank of Nigeria Guideline No. BPS FIRGEN/CIR/02/004 of 2015; BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/05/011 of 2018; Section 10.2.2-10.2.4, 10.3, 10.4 of the CBN Regulations, the Ist to 45th Defendants are not mandated to place a lien on the sums standing in the respective accounts of the 1st- 45th defendants’ customers/account holders.

“Whether having regard to the Central Bank of Nigeria Guideline No. BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/02/004 of 2015; BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/05/011 of 2018; particularly Section 10.2.1 of the Regulations, the Plaintiff is not entitled to a refund of all the funds illegally transferred into the respective accounts of the 1st-45th Defendants’ customers/account holders in the document. marked as Exhibit 1 attached herewith and domiciled with the Defendants where such funds are still available in the customers’ accounts

“Whether having regard to the Central Bank of Nigeria Guideline No. BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/02/004 of 2015; BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/05/011 of 2018; Section 10.2.2-10.2.4, 10.3, 10.4 of the CBN Regulations, where the sums in the customers’ accounts are not sufficient to cover the sums illegally transferred, the 1st-45th Defendants are not mandated to place a lien on any of the sums illegally transferred into the accounts of the customers/account holders domiciled with one or more of the Defendants and more fully shown in the document marked as Exhibit 1 attached herewith, until the entire sums are fully recovered and repaid to the Plaintiff.”

The bank states that upon the determination of the above questions, pray the court following reliefs against the listed banks jointly and severally: “a declaration that by the Central Bank of Nigeria Act 2007, the Central Bank of Nigeria Guideline No. BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/02/004 of 2015; BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/05/011 of 2018; Section 10.2.2 -10.2.4, 10.3, 10.4 of the CBN Regulations, the 1st-45th Defendants has a duty and obligation to protect the banking and payment industry from abuse by dishonest users and to take reasonable steps to forestall any damages of the banking and – payment system whenever any abuse or fraud is within their knowledge or has been brought to their attention.

Advertisement

“A declaration that having regard to the Central Bank of Nigeria Guideline No, BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/02/004 of 2015;

BPS/FIRGEN/CIR/05/011 of 2018: Section 10, 2.2-10.2.4, 10.3, 10.4 of the CBN Regulations, the Plaintiff is entitled to a refund of all the funds illegally transferred into thefendants customers/account holders more fully shown in the document marked as Exhibit 1 attached herewith where such funds are still available in the customers’ accounts.

“An order directing the 1st-45th defendants to immediately reverse and pay to the Plaintiff the sums wrongfully, illegally and illicitly debited from the Plaintiff and transferred into the 1st-45th Defendants customers’ accounts listed in Exhibit 1 in the aggregate sum of N1,133,808,604.31 (One Billion, One Hundred and Thirty-Three Million, Eight Hundred and Eight Thousand, Six Hundred and Four Naira, Thirty-One Kobo) domiciled with one or more of the 1st-45th Defendants or any amount subsequently recovered until the entire sums are fully recovered.

“And such further or other orders as the Court may deem fit to make in the circumstance.”

Lotus Bank supported the motion with 19 paragraphs affidavit deposed to by Gbenga Ojerinde, a Fraud Investigation Officer with the bank. The suit is also attached with a written address and some documentary exhibits.

Advertisement

Some of the banks listed as defendants in the suit, have filed their responses to suit.

However, the Presiding Judge, Justice Daniel Osiagor has adjourned the further hearing of the suit to December, 2025.

Parts of the averments in the affidavit read: “On 20th July 2024, the Plaintiff experienced a system glitch due to a rollback fix carried out on its E-Bills Pay platform. The said rollback fix was carried out to address a previous complaint but led to unintended and unexpected behaviour that allowed the Plaintiff’s customers to initiate transfers to other banks and financial institutions without the accounts of those customers being debited The outcome was that certain customers made multiple transfers to account? held with the Defendants in excess of the balances those customers had in their accounts with the Plaintiff.

“This glitch affected 718 customers of the Plaintiff who made successful withdrawals and transfers from their accounts knowing that they did not have in their accounts with the Plaintiff the sums they were transferring and succeeding in those transfers only because their accounts were not being debited.

“The initial financial exposure of the Plaintiff from this incident is about N1,133,808,604.31 (One Billion, One Hundred and Thirty-Three Million, Eight Hundred and Eight Thousand, Six Hundred and Four Naira, Thirty one Kobo) Now shown to me marked Exhibit 1 is the schedule providing detailed information of the affected customers of the Plaintiff, the Refund Amounts and the banks/other financial institutions warehousing the funds of the affected customers.

Advertisement

“The Plaintiff reported the issue of the system glitch and the resulting Erroneously Retained Credits to the Nigeria Inter-Bank Settlement System Plc (NIBSS), which is the Nigeria central switch responsible for the interoperability of the various players in the banking sector, including banks, mobile service operators, non-banking financial institutions, payment terminal providers, card acquirers, etc. And their customers.

“However, the said beneficiaries were not debited by the Plaintiff for the said transactions and in lieu retained the credit values. Consequently, the Plaintiff is entitled to receive the value of the respective Refund Amounts from the accounts of the beneficiaries of the Erroneously Retained Credits.

“I know that the courts provide a remedy where there is a wrong and that an Oder of this Honourable Court is required to remedy the Plaintiff’s situation to enable the Plaintiff recover the erroneously Retained Credits in the accounts of the affected beneficiaries.

“I also know that the justice of this case demands that the beneficiaries of the” Erroneously Retained Credits are prevented from unjust enrichment in the circumstances of this matter.

“The plaintiff seeks the reliefs sought in this Originating Summons to place restrictions on the said accounts and reverse the Erroneously Retained Credits to the Plaintiff,

Advertisement

“know it is in the interest of justice, equity and fairness that the reliefs sought by the Plaintiff are granted by this Honourable Court.”

Kindly share this post

Ebere Melum-Nwogbo is a trained and practicing journalist. She is passionate about ICT and business journalism. She has over a decade experience spanning money and capital market as well as information technology

E-Financial

Malpass, Ex World Bank Chief Raises Alarm over Nigeria’s Secretive Debt Structures

Published

on

Kindly share this post

David Malpass, former World Bank President, has warned that Nigeria’s increasing reliance on collateral-backed and complex borrowing arrangements could make any future debt restructuring more difficult and discourage investors if the country’s debt position becomes unsustainable.

Malpass, Ex World Bank Chief Raises Alarm over Nigeria’s Secretive Debt Structures

David Malpass, former World Bank President

Malpass, who was 13th president of the World Bank Group,  from April 9, 2019 – June 1, 2023, raised the concern in a World Bank Policy Research Working Paper titled Public Debt and Central Banks, which was based on the Stanley Fischer Memorial Lecture delivered at the World Bank Group’s Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics.

He said increasingly sophisticated collateralised transactions in developing economies, including Nigeria, Angola and Senegal, were creating what he described as “a new race toward seniority in the capital structure.”

In sovereign lending, collateralised creditors may gain priority over other lenders by tying repayment to specific assets, revenues or financial instruments. Malpass warned that the expansion of such arrangements could leave fewer resources available for unsecured creditors and make negotiations more contentious during a debt crisis.

He also questioned the growing use of guarantee products provided by multilateral development banks, arguing that their effectiveness had not been adequately tested during sovereign debt restructurings.

According to him, private lending to distressed or high-risk governments has become less transparent, with some commercial agreements containing non-disclosure clauses that prevent citizens, investors and other creditors from understanding their full implications.

Advertisement

Malpass said debt reconciliation efforts were already being hindered by limited access to sovereign loan contracts, particularly agreements linked to Chinese lending programmes.

The former World Bank chief also criticised the international debt restructuring system, arguing that existing mechanisms had failed to provide timely and meaningful relief to heavily indebted countries.

Beyond debt transparency, Malpass identified exchange rate stability as an important requirement for Nigeria’s economic growth.

He grouped Nigeria with Ethiopia and Egypt among countries where multiple exchange rates and poorly managed currency systems had transferred wealth from low-income earners to politically or economically privileged groups.

He estimated Nigeria’s per capita income at about $1,500, or roughly $4 a day, while noting that median income was likely to be considerably lower because wealth remained concentrated among a small proportion of the population.

Advertisement

Malpass argued that the benefits of credible currency reform could be substantial, pointing to the significantly higher earnings of Nigerians working abroad as evidence of the country’s unrealised productive potential.

He disclosed that, while serving as World Bank president, he held several meetings with Nigeria’s previous administration, cabinet officials and the bank’s Nigeria team to identify reforms capable of accelerating economic growth.

Those discussions highlighted currency stabilisation, exchange rate unification, oil sector reforms, tax changes and agricultural liberalisation, particularly in rice production, as priorities.

Malpass said the reforms could transform Nigeria’s economy in a manner comparable to the policy changes that helped launch China’s sustained period of rapid growth in the 1990s.

Malpass’ warning comes amid continuing scrutiny of Nigeria’s use of unconventional financing to refinance expensive obligations and cover budget deficits.

Advertisement

The International Monetary Fund and Fitch Ratings had earlier raised concerns about the Federal Government’s proposed $5 billion Total Return Swap with First Abu Dhabi Bank, warning that derivatives-based sovereign borrowing could obscure the country’s true debt exposure and complicate future restructuring.

Despite those concerns, Nigeria reportedly accessed an initial tranche of about $1.5 billion from the arrangement.

The controversy follows years of debate over the transparency of Nigeria’s borrowing, including loans linked to crude oil revenues, infrastructure assets and bilateral agreements whose full terms were not always publicly disclosed. With debt-service costs consuming a substantial share of government revenue, the latest warning reinforces concerns that short-term financing relief could create more difficult obligations for future administrations.

 

 

Advertisement

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

Ecobank Nigeria Launches Podcast to Champion African Entrepreneurship, Business Growth

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Ecobank Nigeria has launched Scaling Up!!!, its flagship business storytelling podcast designed to inspire, educate and empower entrepreneurs, founders, business leaders and the next generation of African innovators through authentic conversations with some of the continent’s most accomplished business personalities.

The podcast, which will be available on Ecobank Nigeria’s official YouTube channel and other major digital streaming platforms, reinforces the bank’s commitment to supporting businesses beyond banking by creating a platform where entrepreneurs can learn from the experiences of successful founders, creatives and industry leaders who have built thriving enterprises across diverse sectors.

Featuring compelling conversations on entrepreneurship, leadership, innovation, resilience and business growth, Scaling Up!!! offers practical lessons and real-life insights that aspiring and established entrepreneurs can apply in building sustainable businesses.

The inaugural season features an impressive lineup of distinguished guests, including beauty entrepreneur and Founder/CEO of Beauty by AD, Adeola Adeyemi (Diiadem); renowned filmmaker and Founder of Golden Effects Pictures, Kunle Afolayan; veteran music producer and Founder of Coded Tunes, ID Cabasa; luxury fashion entrepreneur, Ejiro Amos Tafiri; celebrated commercial photographer, Emmanuel Oyeleke; Co-founder and Lead Interior Designer of Siriano Limited, Adewunmi Adegbola; and Founder of Windsor Gallery and Nahous Creative Hub, Richard Vedelago.

Each episode explores the guests’ entrepreneurial journeys, highlighting the opportunities they embraced, the challenges they overcame and the strategies that enabled them to build enduring brands and successful businesses.

Advertisement

Speaking on the launch, Austen Osokpor, Head, Marketing & Corporate Communications, Ecobank Nigeria, said: “Scaling Up!!! reflects Ecobank’s belief that empowering entrepreneurs goes beyond providing financial solutions.

“Through authentic storytelling and insightful conversations, we are creating a platform where business owners can learn directly from people who have successfully navigated the realities of building sustainable enterprises. It is another way we are reinforcing our commitment to driving entrepreneurship, innovation and economic growth across Africa.”

Also speaking, Head, SMEs, Partnerships & Collaborations, Ecobank Nigeria, Omoboye Odu, said: “Entrepreneurs learn best from the experiences of those who have walked the journey before them. Scaling Up!!! provides practical insights, inspiration and valuable lessons that will help founders make better business decisions, overcome challenges and unlock new opportunities for growth.

“The podcast further strengthens Ecobank’s role as a trusted partner supporting SMEs at every stage of their entrepreneurial journey.”

Sharing the creative vision behind the initiative, the Producer of Scaling Up!!!, Jemimah Ugiagbe, said: “Our goal was to create more than just another business podcast. We wanted honest, engaging and relatable conversations that reveal the realities behind success, the setbacks, the resilience, the bold decisions, and the lessons that every entrepreneur can learn from.

Advertisement

“Every episode is designed to leave listeners informed, inspired and motivated to build businesses that create lasting impact.”

The podcast further strengthens Ecobank Nigeria’s position as a trusted partner for entrepreneurs by providing a knowledge-sharing platform that extends beyond traditional banking services.  GeographicReference

Through meaningful conversations with accomplished founders and innovators, the bank continues to demonstrate its commitment to fostering enterprise development, encouraging innovation and promoting sustainable economic growth across Africa.

Scaling Up!!! is targeted at SMEs, entrepreneurs, founders, startups, business executives, creatives, students and young professionals seeking practical business insights from some of Africa’s most respected industry leaders.

New episodes will be released regularly across Ecobank Nigeria’s YouTube channel and other major podcast streaming platforms, offering audiences thought-provoking conversations on entrepreneurship, leadership, innovation and business growth.

Advertisement

Ecobank Nigeria is a member of the Ecobank Group, the leading pan-African banking institution with operations in 33 African countries and international offices in London, Paris, Beijing, and Dubai.

With over 220 branches, more than 36,000 agency banking locations, and robust digital platforms, Ecobank delivers accessible, affordable, and instant banking services. The bank is strategically positioned to support pan-African trade, particularly under the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA).

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

S&P Global Acquires Agusto & Co. to Strengthen Credit Ratings Across Africa

Published

on

Kindly share this post

S&P Global has agreed to acquire a majority stake in Agusto & Co., one of Africa’s oldest and largest domestic credit rating agencies, in a move that signals growing international interest in the continent’s capital markets and credit ecosystem.

According to a joint statement by the rating agencies. The transaction, which is subject to regulatory approvals, will give the global ratings giant a stronger foothold in Africa through Agusto & Co.’s operations in Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, and Rwanda. Financial terms of the deal were not disclosed.

The acquisition marks one of the most significant investments by a global ratings agency in Africa’s domestic credit ratings market in recent years and comes as governments and companies across the continent increasingly rely on local debt markets to finance infrastructure, corporate expansion, and fiscal deficits.

Yann Le Pallec, president of S&P Global Ratings, said the investment reflects the company’s long-term commitment to Africa’s financial markets.

“We are delighted to partner with Agusto & Co. to strengthen our domestic ratings presence across Africa,” Le Pallec said. “This transaction underscores our commitment to supporting growth and transparency in local credit markets throughout the continent.”

Advertisement

He added that combining S&P Global’s international analytical capabilities with Agusto & Co.’s local market knowledge would help improve credit transparency and support investor confidence across African markets.

Founded more than three decades ago, Agusto & Co. has built a reputation as one of Africa’s leading domestic rating agencies, providing credit ratings on banks, corporates, and other institutions. The company has expanded beyond Nigeria into several African markets and has played a key role in the development of domestic bond markets.

For Agusto & Co., the transaction represents a major milestone in its growth strategy and fulfills a long-held ambition to align with a global ratings institution.

“This partnership is a transformational milestone for Agusto & Co. and African capital markets, fulfilling our late founder’s vision of affiliating with a leading global rating agency,” said Yinka Adelekan, managing director of Agusto & Co.

According to Adelekan, the combination of Agusto’s regional expertise with S&P Global’s international resources and analytical network is expected to create broader opportunities for issuers and investors while supporting more transparent and resilient credit markets across Africa.

Advertisement

Despite the ownership change, Agusto & Co. said it will continue operating as an independent domestic ratings agency, maintaining its own rating methodologies and issuing ratings under applicable regulatory frameworks.

That structure is expected to preserve the agency’s regulatory standing in the jurisdictions where it operates while enabling it to benefit from S&P Global’s technology, research capabilities, and global market expertise.

The acquisition also reflects increasing global interest in Africa’s capital markets, where governments are pursuing domestic borrowing strategies and private companies are seeking alternative sources of long-term financing amid tighter global liquidity conditions.

The transaction is expected to close in the second half of 2026, subject to regulatory approvals and other customary closing conditions. S&P Global said the acquisition is not expected to have a material impact on its financial results.

Advertisement

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

Trending