Connect with us

E-Financial

Western Union, Moneygram Hit Nigeria, Others with Charges

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Western Union and Moneygram, the world’s leading money transfer companies, have been accused of charging a premium of up to 12 per cent on remittances into Africa, according to a recently released report by UK-based think tank The Overseas Development Institute (ODI), according to the Banker

Yet the banks in Africa appear to charge even higher.

The ODI report claimed that the two money transfer operators’ (MTOs) excessive charges cost African migrants approximately $1.8 billion annually, a significant leap from global rates.

“Migrants sending $200 home can expect to pay 12 per cent in charges, which is almost double the global average. While the governments of the G8 and the G20 have pledged to reduce charges to five per cent, there is no evidence of any decline in the fees incurred by Africa’s diaspora. There is no justification for the high charges incurred by African migrants,” the ODI said.

While it is difficult to pin down just how many Africans live outside their countries of origin, an assortment of statistics can paint a picture.

The World Bank said in 2011 that the number of Africans that have migrated outside their country of origin in recent decades is “conservatively” estimated to be more than 30 million (according to the United Nations, some 232 million international migrants are living in the world today) and has grown more than any other migrant community at 53 per cent in the past 10 years.

The OECD estimated that one in every nine persons born in Africa with a tertiary diploma lived in an OECD country in 2010-2011.

At the same time, the highest share of low educated migrants in the same period was recorded for migrants born in Sao Tomé and Principe (73 per cent), Cape Verde (68 per cent), Mali (67 per cent) and Guinea-Bissau (66 per cent).

The latest World Bank figures show that remittances from migrants are expected to rise to $436 billion this year, more than three times what poor countries receive in overseas aid. That number is expected to rise to $516 billion in 2016.

Nigeria alone accounted for about $21 billion, or 65.6 per cent of flows into the region, and is forecasted to bring in $41 billion of remittances in 2016.

The booming activity has led many banks in the region to establish Diaspora Banking services, including bonds, investments and remittance offerings.

However according to the ODI, banks are part of the price problem. While the ODI does not allege any sort of rate fixing between the two transfer companies, it notes that each one’s “exclusivity agreements” with banks and remittance agents in Africa have been one factor in the charges hike.

“Governments and regulatory authorities in sending countries should do far more to promote competition and encourage innovation,” The ODI said. “In an age of mobile banking, internet transfers and rapid technological innovation, no region should be paying charges at the levels reported for Africa.”

Yet remittance corridors within Africa actually charge the most excessive prices. The ODI reports that migrant workers from Mozambique sending money home from South Africa, or Ghanaians remitting from Nigeria, can face charges of more than 20 per cent.

“In several African countries, banks are the only agency authorised to conduct money-transfer operations, and typically partner with large MTOs,” the report noted. In countries where only banks are authorised to pay remittances, such as South Africa, Mozambique and Lesotho, half are agents of Western Union and MoneyGram.

 According to The International Fund for Agricultural Development, banks in partnership with Western Union service about 41 per cent of payments and 65 per cent of all pay-out location.

The ODI says that there are 29 countries in Africa where banks account for over half of the in-bound remittance payments; in Ethiopia, Niger and Nigeria the share is more than 80 per cent.

All this begs the question: what do Diaspora Banking products at commercial banks provide? The service has risen over the past few years, and is already offered through many Sub Saharan African banks attempting to reach citizens scattered throughout the world.

Yet ODI reports that all of the world’s top ten remittance-charging corridors are in Sub Saharan Africa, with South Africa and Tanzania “figuring in all but one of these corridors.”

Migrants from Malawi, Mozambique and Zimbabwe employed in South Africa, and Ugandans remitting money home from Kenya face charges well over 20 per cent. In Ghana, Nigerian workers can expect to pay 39 per cent in charges.

“The very high charges levied on remittance corridors to and within Africa reflect the central role of banks – the most costly transfer vehicle,” said the ODI. Why are remittance charges for Africa so high?

The ODI says it’s difficult to answer that question, largely due to the “opaque nature of commercial operations.” For MTOs, cost structures and foreign currency exchange fees, including currency volatility measures, are not openly provided and no MTO has disclosed the terms of their commercial agreements with African banks.


Kindly share this post

Nigeria CommunicationsWeek believes that technology makes life more exciting and helps improve the lives of people around Nigeria and indeed the world. So since 2007, we have devoted our energy to independent reportage of technology and how they affect lives.

E-Financial

Crypto Exchanges Begin Delisting Naira from P2P Platforms- SEC

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Crypto exchanges have commenced delisting of the Naira from Peer-to-Peer (P2P) trading platforms, following directives of the Office of the National Security Adviser and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Crypto Exchanges Begin Delisting Naira from P2P Platforms- SEC

P2P trading in the realm of cryptos is a decentralized method that allows individuals to buy and sell digital assets directly with one another.

In this system, P2P trading platforms serve as intermediaries, facilitating secure and trust-based transactions.

SEC explained that its checks have indicated that the Naira has been removed as a fiat currency option for transactions on KuCoin platform and the exchange has already begun the necessary adjustments to its technology to accommodate the delisting of the Naira as soon as practicable.

It explained that the removal of the Naira from the platforms limits the ability to manipulate the exchange rates against the Nigerian currency which is expected to further strengthen the value of the naira.

Dr. Emomotimi Agama, acting director general of SEC, reacting to the delisting by KuCoin, expressed delight that the crypto exchanges were heeding the directives of ONSA and SEC, describing it as a welcome development.

He stated: “We are happy that they have started complying with the directives by the ONSA.  We ask that those involved in sharp practices that undermine national interest should cease and desist. It is in our interest as a people to protect what belongs to us.  Anyone that disobeys directives should be ready to face the full weight of the law”.

Agama added that as the apex regulator of the capital market, “SEC is co-operating  with the Office of the National Security Adviser, the  Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and other relevant agencies to achieve the national objective of making sure that illegality is not allowed to thrive”.

 

 

 


Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

Court Backs Banks to Collect Customers’ Social Media Handles

Published

on

Kindly share this post

A federal high court in Lagos has struck out a case against the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) over its directive requiring banks to collect and verify social media handles as part of their know-your-customer (KYC) requirement.

Court Backs Banks to Collect Customers’ Social Media Handles

In June 2023, the apex bank issued the directive, saying the aim is to prevent financial crime, and terrorism, as well as boost the precision and thoroughness of customer identification.

Chris Eke, the applicant and a customer, represented by Olubunmi Abayomi-Olukunle, a lawyer, had filed suit number FHC/L/CS/1281/2023 in July 2023, arguing the CBN’s directive infringed upon constitutional rights, particularly section 37 of the 1999 constitution.

Nnamdi Dimgba, presiding judge, struck out the suit filed by Eke, which sought a declaration that the regulation as contained in section 6(a)(iv) of the CBN (customer due diligence) Regulations, 2023, is “undemocratic, unconstitutional, null and void”.

The CBN, in its response to the suit, filed a notice of preliminary objection, challenging the competence of the suit and disagreeing with the claim of interference with the applicant’s private life.

In his judgment, Dimgba held that the notice of preliminary objection had merit, subsequently striking out the suit.

The judge ruled that providing a social media handle is equivalent to providing email and phone numbers for potential customers, and therefore, it does not violate the right to privacy.

“First, the applicant claims that the requirements on the CBN regulations for financial institutions to request and collect the social media handle of its customers as part of KYC infringes on his right to privacy,” the judge said.

“This claim is very ambitious and amounts to a very far throw. The said regulations are directed to and apply to financial institutions.  It does not apply to private individuals such as the applicant.

“Even if, as appears to be argued, that the regulations itself would inevitably affect the applicant, this claim is speculative for the simple reason that in nowhere in the affidavit in support was it stated that the applicant operates an account with a financial institution and that the said institution had demanded his social media handle.”

Consequently, the judge said the suggestion that he would be negatively affected by the regulation is very “speculative and at large”.

He said there is a lack of evidence suggesting financial institutions have implemented the regulation, and it is causing disruptions and inconvenience.

Furthermore, Dimgba said if the applicant is “irritated by the requirement of the regulation”, he has a choice to “refuse to do business with any bank insisting on the information as part of its social media handle, but to seek other alternatives”.

PROVISION OF SOCIAL MEDIA HANDLES TO BANKS DO NOT TRANSLATE TO BREACH’

Dimgba said banks asking customers or potential clients to provide their social media handles is not a breach of privacy.

He said the essence of having a social media account was for one to be publicly visible communication-wise.

According to the judge, a social media handle, being in the public space, can be accessed by everyone whether or not consent was obtained.

As a result, he said it would be unreasonable to hold the respondent in breach of privacy.

“The apprehension of the Applicant of his social interactions being monitored is manifestly speculative in itself and rather incredulous to believe that the financial institutions have the luxury of time to concern itself with such frivolities,” the judge said.

 

 


Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

CBN Grants Approval to 14 New IMTOs  to Spur Liquidity

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has said that it has granted 14 new International Money Transfer Operators, IMTOs Approval-in-Principle (AIP) to double foreign-currency remittance inflows through formal channels amid foreign currency crisis.

CBN Grants Approval to 14 New IMTOs  to Spur Liquidity

Hakama Sidi Ali, acting director of Corporate Communications, CBN, disclosed this in a statement that the he initiative will help increase the sustained supply of foreign exchange in the official market by promoting greater competition and innovation amongst IMTOs, lowering the cost of remittance transactions and boosting financial inclusion.

CBN’s thinking is that increasing formal remittance flows, which are one of the major sources of foreign exchange and account for over 6 per cent of gross domestic product, would help ease the historical volatility in Nigeria’s exchange rate caused by external factors, such as fluctuations in foreign investment and oil export proceeds.

This will spur liquidity in Nigeria’s Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEX), augmenting price discovery to enable a market-driven fair value for the naira,” Olayemi Cardoso, the CBN Governor, recently disclosed the apex bank’s target to double remittance flows into Nigeria within a year, which he firmly believed was possible.

On Wednesday, the Naira recorded its first N61 gain against the dollar at the foreign exchange market for the first time after weeks of decline.

 

 


Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

Trending