Connect with us

E-Financial

Supreme Court Refuses to Set Aside N2.5Bn Judgement against Stanbic IBTC

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Stanbic IBTC Bank Plc has failed in its attempt to have the Supreme Court of Nigeria, Abuja set aside the N2.5 billion judgment delivered against the bank.

 

The five-man panel of Justices of the Supreme Court, Musa Dattijo Muhammad, John Inyang Okoro, Amiru Sanusi, Paul Adamu Galinje and Uwani Musa Abba Aji, in their ruling unanimously agreed that the bank’s application to set aside the judgment of the court lacked merit, consequently, a cost of N500, 000 was awarded against the bank.

 

Mr. O. Ayanlaja, SAN, and Mr. Tayo Oyetibo, SAN, the bank’s lawyers, had approached the apex court, urging it to set aside the judgement of the court in respect of appeal filed before the court by Stanbic IBTC Bank PLC against Longterm Global Capital Ltd. and Mr. Patrick Akinkuotu, which was dismissed, to be set aside on the basis that it could be set down for rehearing on its merits.

Advertisement

 

The bank’s application was based on ground that the court reached its decision without a consideration of its brief of argument at the lower court and on ground that the brief was not the exact replica of what was  ordered by the lower court.

 

The five-man panel of the Supreme Court judges unanimously agreed that although there were instances where the apex Court could reverse itself, it i was not in the instance case.

 

Advertisement

In the lead judgment delivered by Justice Uwani Musa Abba Ali in dismissing the application, he said: “I cannot but fully agree with the submission of the learned counsel to the respondents that this application is frivolous, baseless, scandalous and contemptuous to be dismissed.

 

“There is a synergy of concurrence in reasoning and decisions from the trial court upward that this case was decided on its merits and smacks of any oversight or miscarriage of justice, thus cannot be reviewed and therefore does not fall within the genre and the circumstances of judgments to be set aside.

 

“There is no point saying that none of the conditions that would justify the setting aside by this court of its judgment earlier delivered on March 15, 2019. The finality of this court’s decision cannot and should never be compromised. The moment this court sets undeserved or unwarranted precedent by indiscriminately setting aside its own decision in the absence of special and compelling reason to do so, will certainly amount to setting dangerous precedent which will surely open flood gate for parties to undeservedly file similar applications and will thereby continue to bring no end to litigation. This application should outrightly be refused and dismissed unhesitatingly.”

Advertisement

Kindly share this post

Nigeria CommunicationsWeek believes that technology makes life more exciting and helps improve the lives of people around Nigeria and indeed the world. So since 2007, we have devoted our energy to independent reportage of technology and how they affect lives.

E-Financial

FCT Court Awards Ex-Customers N15m against Stanbic IBTC over Data Privacy Breach

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Federal Capital Territory High Court has ordered Stanbic IBTC Bank Limited to pay N15 million in damages to two former customers after finding that the bank unlawfully retained and processed their personal information after they had terminated their banking relationship.

FCT Court Awards Ex-Customers N15m against Stanbic IBTC over Data Privacy Breach

In a judgment delivered on July 29, Justice Kayode Agunloye also directed the bank to erase all personal data belonging to the claimants that it is not legally required to retain and restrained it from further processing or using such information without lawful authority or the customers’ consent.

The court held that the bank breached the Nigeria Data Protection Act (NDPA) 2023, the claimants’ constitutional right to privacy under Section 37 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), and provisions of the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act (FCCPA).

The suit, marked CV/2190/25, was filed by David Ogundipe and Salami Tolulope Ibrahim, who argued that Stanbic IBTC continued to process their personal data for marketing purposes even after they had closed their corporate account with the bank.

According to the claimants, the account was shut following unresolved issues with the bank.

Advertisement

Despite the closure, they alleged that Stanbic IBTC continued sending promotional emails and text messages to their personal and corporate email addresses as well as their telephone numbers.

The customers said their solicitors later wrote to the bank demanding that all marketing communications cease and that their personal data should no longer be processed for promotional purposes.

Although the bank reportedly acknowledged the request and assured them that the messages would stop, the unsolicited communications allegedly continued, prompting them to seek judicial intervention.

In his ruling, Justice Agunloye held that once the banking relationship had ended and the customers had withdrawn their consent, the bank no longer had any lawful basis to process their personal data for marketing activities.

The judge ruled that the continued use of the claimants’ information amounted to an infringement of their constitutional right to privacy and constituted an unfair trade practice under the FCCPA.

Advertisement

The court consequently ordered Stanbic IBTC to delete all personal information relating to the claimants that it is not legally required to retain and to cease every form of data processing except where permitted by law or regulatory obligations.

Justice Agunloye also granted a perpetual injunction restraining the bank, its officers and agents from retaining, processing, transmitting or using the claimants’ personal data for marketing, promotional or any other unauthorised purpose.

While the claimants sought N250 million as damages, the court awarded N15 million as general damages, describing the amount as adequate compensation for the persistent unsolicited communications, the bank’s failure to honour requests for data erasure and the violation of the customers’ privacy rights.

The bank was further ordered to pay N500,000 as the cost of the suit, while the claim for N7 million as litigation expenses was dismissed for lack of sufficient proof.

Justice Agunloye directed that all monetary awards would attract 10 per cent post-judgment interest annually until fully settled.

Advertisement

However, the court declined to order the complete deletion of every record relating to the claimants, holding that banks remain under statutory obligations to retain certain customer records in compliance with financial regulations and anti-money laundering laws.

Reacting to the verdict, counsel to the claimants, O.E. Oluwadamisi of Earnest Attorneys LP, described the decision as a landmark judgment for data protection in Nigeria.

He said the ruling reinforces the mandatory nature of compliance with the Nigeria Data Protection Act and makes it clear that organisations cannot continue processing customers’ personal information after consent has been withdrawn unless authorised by law.

One of the successful claimants, David Ogundipe, welcomed the judgment, saying it represented a victory not only for the litigants but also for millions of Nigerians whose personal information is held by corporate organisations.

He expressed hope that the ruling would encourage institutions across the country to strengthen compliance with data protection laws and place greater respect on customers’ privacy rights.

Advertisement

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

CBN Exposes over 13,000 BVNs Tied to Fraud as Banks Tighten Security

Published

on

Kindly share this post

The number of Bank Verification Numbers (BVNs) on the Nigerian banking industry’s fraud watchlist reached 13,117, according to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN).

CBN Exposes over 13,000 BVNs Tied to Fraud as Banks Tighten Security

This is coming as banks strengthen efforts to detect and prevent financial crimes.

According to the CBN’s 2025 Annual Report and Statement of Accounts, the number of BVNs on the banking industry’s fraud watchlist increased from 9,476 in 2024 to 13,117 in 2025. This represents a 38.4 per cent increase.

The apex bank explained that commercial banks, including Access Bank, Zenith Bank, United Bank for Africa (UBA), and other financial institutions, added 3,641 new BVNs to the watchlist during the year.

The report said the increase reflects stronger fraud monitoring, improved compliance, better risk management, and enhanced systems for detecting suspicious transactions.

Advertisement

It added that the higher number does not necessarily mean fraud has increased, but shows banks are becoming more active in identifying and blocking suspicious activities.

The report also revealed that consumer lending declined for the first time since 2019.

Outstanding consumer credit dropped by 19.89 per cent, falling from N4.72 trillion in 2024 to N3.78 trillion in 2025.

The CBN attributed the decline to high interest rates, which made borrowing more expensive for many Nigerians.

Personal loans recorded the biggest drop, falling to N1.85 trillion.

Advertisement

However, retail loans rose by 63.77 per cent to N1.94 trillion, making them the largest category of consumer credit for the first time in several years.

 

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

E-Financial

CBN Orders N19Bn Refunds to Customers as Complaints Rise

Published

on

Kindly share this post

Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), has ordered banks to refund a total  N19.12 billion to customers for illegal deductions and poor complaint handling.

CBN Orders N19Bn Refunds to Customers as Complaints Rise

This is coming as bank customers lodged 23,129 complaints against financial institutions in 2025, representing 11 per cent increase over the previous year.

The apex bank also imposed N1.69 billion in penalties on financial institutions for regulatory breaches, poor complaint handling and failure to comply with its directives, according to its 2025 Annual Report.

The CBN attributed the increase in complaints  to  growing public confidence in its consumer protection framework rather than a deterioration in banking services.

The report stated: “The Bank received a total of 23,129 complaints from consumers of financial services in 2025, a rise of 10.53 per cent above the 20,925 in 2024. The trend reflected increased awareness and improved confidence in the Bank’s consumer complaint resolution process.”

Advertisement

The apex bank added: “A total of 18,824 complaints were resolved, indicating a 9.36 per cent increase over the 17,213 complaints resolved in 2024.”

On the value of disputed transactions, the CBN said: “Total claims in local currency increased to N40.61 billion from N17.13 billion in 2024. Foreign currency claims also rose, reaching $344.2 million compared with $1.06 million in the preceding year.”

According to the report, “Based on the resolved complaints, the sums of N19.12 billion and $329.3 million were refunded in 2025, compared with N9.66 billion and $0.67 million in 2024.”

The CBN said it strengthened enforcement against erring financial institutions during the year.

It stated: “During the review period, the Bank imposed 11 penalties on financial institutions totalling N1.26 billion for infractions ranging from regulatory breaches and failure to respond to regulatory queries.”

Advertisement

The report further disclosed: “In addition, the Bank imposed 21 penalties on financial institutions to the tune of N430 million for infractions ranging from delays in resolving customer complaints to failure to comply with the Bank’s directives.”

Kindly share this post
Continue Reading

Trending